Lists: Comedy

Brief Synopsis: "Teenage Mary Cummings, who has "been Born Again her whole life," is about to enter her senior year at American Eagle Christian High School near Baltimore with her Fundamentalist Christian friends Hilary Faye and Veronica, the three of whom have formed a girl group called the Christian Jewels. Everything seems perfect—until Mary’s "perfect Christian boyfriend" Dean tells her, as they’re swimming underwater, that he thinks he's gay."

Overall Ranking: 248 (Rank from 2004: # 3)

Adjusted* Rating:
(lowest rating dropped)

Ratings Breakdown
(The Mixed Bag)

Buttery 66.67%
Regular 33.33%
Half-Popped 0%
Stale 0%
Burnt 0%


Login To Rate

Reviewer Rating Review Secondary Ratings
David Baruffi97
Rob from GuysFilmQuest85Comedy: 7
Sex Appeal: 2
Scary: 2
Rewatch: 7
Wayne of Man I Love Films80(full review)

People Involved

  • Jena Malone (Mary)
  • Mandy Moore (Hilary Faye)
  • Macaulay Culkin (Roland)
  • Patrick Fugit (Patrick)
  • Heather Matarazzo (Tia)
  • Eva Amurri (Cassandra)
  • Martin Donovan (Pastor Skip)
  • Mary-Louise Parker (Lillian)
  • Brian Dannelly (Director)