list
This list of movies is divided up into Ranked movies, which have been rated enough times to have a ranking, and then a list of other movies from this category/genre which haven't been rated enough times.
Also, there is a version of this list filtered down to movies available to you for streaming in this genre, if you're logged in and have provided a list of which streaming services to which you've subscribed.
Also, there is a version of this list filtered down to movies available to you for streaming in this genre, if you're logged in and have provided a list of which streaming services to which you've subscribed.
Ranked Movies
| Rank | Movie | Avg | Streaming Options | Ratings Breakdown |
| 1 |  Lord of the Rings: Return of the King | 89.48% | Amazon Prime Video, HBO Max | |
| 2 |  Avengers: Endgame | 88.43% | Disney Plus, DIRECTV, TNT, TBS, tru TV | |
| 3 |  Superman II (Donner cut) | 85.71% | HBO Max | |
| 4 |  Avengers: Infinity War | 85.64% | Disney Plus | |
| 5 |  Pan's Labyrinth | 85.57% | Starz Roku Premium Channel, Starz, DIRECTV, Starz Amazon Channel | |
| 6 |  A Monster Calls | 85.44% | Netflix | |
| 7 |  The Shape of Water | 85.43% | fuboTV, FXNow, DIRECTV | |
| 8 |  Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring | 85.42% | Amazon Prime Video, HBO Max | |
| 9 |  Lord of the Rings: Two Towers | 84.89% | Amazon Prime Video, HBO Max | |
| 10 |  Dracula (1931) | 84.33% | Criterion Channel | |
| 11 |  Edward Scissorhands | 83.5% | Amazon Prime Video, Disney Plus | |
| Rank | Movie | Avg | Streaming Options | Ratings Breakdown |
| 12 |  Army of Darkness | 83.2% | None | |
| 13 |  Hellboy II: The Golden Army | 82.43% | None | |
| 14 |  The Witch | 79.47% | HBO Max, DIRECTV | |
| 15 |  Crow, The | 79.38% | Paramount Plus, Paramount+ Amazon Channel, Paramount+ Roku Premium Channel, Paramount+ Showtime | |
| 16 |  Beetlejuice | 79.33% | HBO Max | |
| 17 |  Hellboy | 79.23% | HBO Max, Hoopla, DIRECTV | |
| 18 |  Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 | 79% | Disney Plus | |
| 19 |  Corpse Bride | 78.33% | HBO Max | |
| 20 |  Frankenweenie | 77.8% | Disney Plus | |
| 21 |  Blade II | 77.56% | Hulu | |
| 22 |  Doctor Strange | 76.68% | Disney Plus | |
| Rank | Movie | Avg | Streaming Options | Ratings Breakdown |
| 23 |  Bram Stoker's Dracula | 76% | Amazon Prime Video, Paramount Plus, Paramount+ Amazon Channel, EPIX Amazon Channel, Paramount+ Roku Premium Channel, DIRECTV, Epix | |
| 24 |  Nightmare Before Christmas | 75.5% | Disney Plus | |
| 25 |  Trollhunter (Trolljegeren) | 75.06% | Hoopla | |
| 26 |  Avengers: Age of Ultron | 74.32% | Disney Plus, DIRECTV, Syfy, Sling TV Orange and Blue, TNT, TBS, tru TV | |
| 27 |  Man of Steel | 74.02% | HBO Max | |
| 28 |  Blade | 73.36% | Hulu | |
| 29 |  Superman/Batman: Apocalypse | 73.33% | HBO Max | |
| 30 |  Lemony Snickets A Series Of Unfortunate Events | 73% | Netflix, Paramount Plus, Paramount+ Amazon Channel, EPIX Amazon Channel, Epix Roku Premium Channel, DIRECTV, Epix, CBS | |
| 30 |  Sleepy Hollow | 73% | fuboTV, AMC+ Amazon Channel, AMC+ Roku Premium Channel, DIRECTV | |
| 32 |  Crimson Peak | 71.7% | Netflix | |
| 33 |  Coraline | 71.38% | None | |
| Rank | Movie | Avg | Streaming Options | Ratings Breakdown |
| 34 |  Where the Wild Things Are | 71% | HBO Max | |
| 34 |  Willow | 71% | Disney Plus | |
| 36 |  Krampus | 70.33% | fuboTV, Peacock Premium, DIRECTV, USA Network | |
| 37 |  Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, The (2013) | 70.03% | Amazon Prime Video, HBO Max, DIRECTV | |
| 38 |  NeverEnding Story, The | 68.8% | HBO Max, Hoopla | |
| 39 |  Hocus Pocus | 68.33% | Disney Plus | |
| 40 |  Justice League | 67.73% | HBO Max, DIRECTV | |
| 41 |  Blade: Trinity | 67% | Hulu | |
| 42 |  Imaginarium of Dr Parnassus | 66.5% | None | |
| 43 |  Into the Woods | 65.79% | Disney Plus | |
| 44 |  Thor: The Dark World | 65.64% | Disney Plus, Starz Roku Premium Channel, Starz, DIRECTV, Starz Amazon Channel | |
| Rank | Movie | Avg | Streaming Options | Ratings Breakdown |
| 45 |  Brightburn | 65% | fuboTV, DIRECTV, Sling TV Orange and Blue, USA Network | |
| 46 |  Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice | 64.61% | HBO Max | |
| 47 |  Goosebumps | 64.14% | Netflix, Netflix basic with Ads | |
| 48 |  Horns | 63.75% | None | |
| 49 |  Wonder Woman 1984 | 63.08% | HBO Max | |
| 50 |  Dark Phoenix | 62.5% | Disney Plus, fuboTV, DIRECTV | |
| 51 | Labyrinth | 59.75% | Netflix | |
| 52 | Venom | 58.9% | Starz Roku Premium Channel, Starz, DIRECTV, Starz Amazon Channel | |
| 53 | Snow White and the Huntsman | 58.36% | Netflix, fuboTV, DIRECTV, USA Network | |
| 54 | Maleficent | 57.95% | None | |
| 55 | Underworld: Evolution | 57% | Hulu, aha | |
| Rank | Movie | Avg | Streaming Options | Ratings Breakdown |
| 56 | The House with a Clock in Its Walls | 55% | fuboTV, FXNow, DIRECTV | |
| 57 | Abraham Lincoln: Vampire Hunter | 54.58% | Amazon Prime Video | |
| 58 | Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children | 53.6% | Disney Plus, fuboTV, FXNow, DIRECTV | |
| 59 | The Dark Tower | 51.75% | fuboTV, FXNow, DIRECTV | |
| 60 | The Huntsman Winter's War | 51.53% | fuboTV, Peacock Premium, DIRECTV, USA Network | |
| 61 | Dracula Untold | 50.09% | Netflix | |
| 62 | Underworld: Awakening | 46.86% | Hulu, aha | |
| 63 | Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance | 42.26% | DIRECTV, TNT, TBS, tru TV | |
| 64 | Ghost Rider | 37.52% | DIRECTV, TNT, TBS, tru TV | |
| 65 | Red Riding Hood | 22.65% | HBO Max | |
| Rank | Movie | Avg | Streaming Options | Reviewer Ratings |
Un-Ranked Movies
| Movie | Current Avg | Streaming |
| Dark Crystal, The | 82.5% | fuboTV, Showtime Amazon Channel, Showtime Roku Premium Channel, Showtime, DIRECTV, Paramount+ Showtime |
| Maleficent: Mistress of Evil | 78% | Disney Plus |
| Beowulf | 70% | Netflix, Hoopla, Film Movement Plus, Netflix basic with Ads, CBS |
| Conan the Barbarian | 70% | Paramount+ Showtime |
| Secret of NIMH, The | 70% | Hoopla |
| Superman: Red Son | 70% | HBO Max |
| The Lord of the Rings | 68% | None |
| Masters of the Universe | 66% | HBO Max, DIRECTV |
| Hobbit, The (1977) | 65.5% | None |
| Heavy Metal | 61% | None |
| The Spiderwick Chronicles | 61% | HBO Max, DIRECTV |
| Movie | Current Avg | Streaming |
| Gretel & Hansel | 57% | None |
| Underworld | 49.5% | Hulu |
| Underworld: Blood Wars | 47% | None |
| Van Helsing | 42% | Peacock Premium |
| Abraham Lincoln vs. Zombies | 40% | None |
| Dragonslayer | 40% | Paramount Plus, Paramount+ Amazon Channel, Paramount+ Roku Premium Channel, CBS |
| Underworld: Rise of the Lycans | 40% | Hulu |
| WolfCop | 30% | Hoopla, Shudder Amazon Channel |
| Neverending Story III: Escape from Fantasia, The | 25% | None |
| Dracula vs. Frankenstein | 0% | None. |
| Dracula: Dead and Loving It | 0% | None. |
| Movie | Current Avg | Streaming |
| Hellboy | 0% | None. |
| Legend | 0% | None. |
| NeverEnding Story II: The Next Chapter, The | 0% | HBO Max |
| Roald Dahl's The Witches | 0% | None. |
| Solomon Kane | 0% | None. |
| The 13th Warrior | 0% | None. |
| The Black Cauldron | 0% | None. |
| The Brothers Grimm | 0% | None. |
| The Crow: City of Angels | 0% | None. |
| The Witches | 0% | None. |
| Movie | Current Avg | Streaming |